Yareah Magazine

Ethics: Aristotle PDF Print E-mail
  
Tuesday, 01 December 2009 00:00

http://www.yareah.com/images/bandera1_p.gifRon Schuler 

 http://terpconnect.umd.edu/~wkallfel/PHIL100Sp2006/Sects0203-4,0207%20(Kallfelz)/plato%20and%20aristotle.jpg
 Plato and Aristotle by Raphael
The diametric differences in approach between Aristotle and Plato, Aristotle's teacher at the Academy in Athens, are deeply embedded in much of what Western philosophers have bickered about for centuries since -- endless variations on the themes of Plato's belief in an objective reality existing apart from human sensation, and Aristotle's emphasis on intelligent observation of physical phenomena.

An orientation toward the physical may have been cooked into Aristotle's veins: his father Nicomachus was physician to the Macedonian king Amyntas II, and it is said that he began training Aristotle to follow in the profession from a young age.  Nicomachus died when Aristotle was 10, but certainly there may have been some attempt on the part of Aristotle's guardian to carry out Nicomachus' wishes in sending the 17-year old to study in Plato's famous Academy. 

 Although Plato was in Syracuse when Aristotle arrived, it did not take him long after his return to identify Aristotle as a young man of superior capabilities, and soon he began to call young Aristotle "the intellect of the school."  Aristotle eventually became a teacher at the Academy, possibly instructing in rhetoric and dialectic -- the art of question and answer.

When Aristotle was 37, Plato died, leaving the Academy in the hands of his mathematically-oriented nephew Speusippus.  Numbers not being Aristotle's cup of tea, he left the Academy.  His old ties with powerful Macedonia (including with its ruler, his boyhood friend Philip) made him a marketable commodity, and he soon accepted the invitation of Hermias, king of Atarneus, to teach.  Hermias, seen by some as a living embodiment of Plato's "philosopher-king," certainly saw the advantages of keeping the well-affiliated Macedonian around, and married his niece to Aristotle.  Despite his loyalty to Hermias, Aristotle began a now-lost treatise at this time which suggested that it was a disadvantage for a king to be a philosopher, that instead a king who relied on the fresh perspectives of wise philosophers would be more effective than Plato's philosopher-king.

It is unclear whether the shortcomings of Hermias' own intellect had anything to do with it, but in 344 BCE, Hermias was captured and executed by invading Persians.  Aristotle fled to the island of Lesbos, where in exile he returned to his childhood anatomy lessons, gathering specimens of marine life along the island's shore, inspecting them with his scalpel and recording copious notes about them. The idyll proved to have a profound influence on Aristotle's thought, gradually turning him away from Plato's concept of a higher plane of reality and back to the present fundamentals -- the scent of mollusks and sea air, the taste of salt water on his skin, the rush of the wind and the heat of the Aegean sun.

He left Lesbos for Macedonia after a couple of years, by legend to tutor Philip's son, the future Alexander the Great.  Whether or not he was Alexander's tutor remains a matter of conjecture, but the close connections between the two are not: Alexander later saw to it that local specimens of flora and fauna from his conquests were sent back to Aristotle's library, and when Alexander became king in 336 BCE, he funded Aristotle's launch of the Lyceum in Athens, a rival school to the Academy.

Rather than engaging students in dialogues as Plato did, Aristotle preferred to lecture, wandering through the halls of the Lyceum with students gathered in tow.  More importantly, however, Aristotle expanded the scope of education, defining new disciplines such as biology and psychology and lecturing on everything from politics and ethics to metaphysics, economics and rhetoric.  It is the Aristotle of the Lyceum -- the squat, pinky-ring wearing, spindly-legged man in his late 40s and 50s, exceptionally well-organized and an avid collector of all manner of material things -- that we have incidentally come to know best.

The only texts by Aristotle which survive are his lecture notes from this period, which is a little like trying to get to know Dickens from a set of storyboard sketches, perhaps.  Nonetheless, Aristotle's lecture notes reveal his concern with breaking things (or questions) down to their constituent parts for more manageable data analysis, with classification so that information could be easily accessed (his classifications of plants and animal life still form the basis of modern biological classification) and with the extraction of knowledge through the use of logic.

Principal among his works are Organon, on logic, illustrating the understanding of scientific questions through the implementation of systems of axioms; Physics, a review of astronomy, meteorology, plants and animals; First Philosophy, or Metaphysics, an analysis of the most general, abstract features of reality, the principles which define existence (including a description of Aristotle's God-like "Prime Mover," the first cause of all existence); his work on ethics, dedicated to his son Nico, the Nicomachean Ethics; Rhetoric; and Poetics.

His methodologies for understanding existence were derived from observation.  His description of four causes for every real thing in nature (the material, based on a thing's component substances; the efficient, or the process which produces a thing; the formal, a thing's ultimate shape; and the final, that which gives it its purpose or meaning) and 10 categories of being (substance, quantity, quality, relation, place, time, position, state, action and affection) are quite far removed from Plato's extrasensory interests, revealing the mind of a diagnostic mechanic.  If Plato might want to engage you in a discussion of your "stuff" with the aim of turning you toward unseen absolutes, Aristotle would not be able to keep his paws off your "stuff," taking it apart and putting it back together and showing you things you never guessed you'd ever know about your "stuff."

While the enveloping sense of authority throughout Aristotle's writings may be seen as somewhat self-important and overbearing (especially to his enemies), the old teacher is thought to have been generous and affectionate.  When Alexander died in 323 BCE, Aristotle's enemies mobilized the anti-Macedonian sentiment in Athens and officially charged Aristotle with the crime of impiety. Recalling the fate of Socrates and his failed attempt to defend himself from similar false charges, Aristotle fled Athens for Chalcis, and died there of a stomach ailment after only a few months.  His body was taken back to his hometown of Stagira and his ashes were buried with great honors.

Meanwhile, the Lyceum remained open until 529 CE when Justinian closed all "philosophy" schools.  Aristotle's influence on the intellectual histories of Islam and the West has been pervasive: his work, particularly his Metaphysics and his rational model for the existence of a Prime Mover, was commented upon and engaged by such diverse writers as Ibn Sina, Ibn Rushd, Aquinas and Maimonides; and his conceptions of biology and astronomy defined most of what came afterwards, even as the empirical value of his conclusions have gradually eroded since the Renaissance.

Read more about Ron Schuler:

http://rsparlourtricks.blogspot.com/

 

*Yareah magazine es una revista cultural fundada y dirigida por el escritor Martín Cid: http://www.martincid.com
**Created and edited by the writer Martin Cid: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

 

 

Trackback(0)
Comments (14)Add Comment
0
ugg boots
written by discount ugg boots, December 27, 2009

It is my Ugg Boots great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post here. I like that very

much. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful. Thanks so much for sharing. I can be very

good reader&listener if you are same searching for all to be good. Appreciate Ugg boots for your time!

Happy New Year!!!
0
http://www.ugg-boot-shoes.net
written by UGG Australia, December 29, 2009
I tried this code in my Joomla component. But I got an error message saying "Could not instantiate mail function".

I an undergraduate and developing a Joomla ugg boots component for my project. I have just deployed and running Joomla in XAMPP server.

I don't have any mail server.

In Joomla installation, I've given my personal email. Is there any way to send emails ( just for theUGG Australia purpose of testing &

project demonstration) using my Gmail or other account?

Your reply would be appreciated.

Thanks in advance!
0
http://www.dunk2u.com
written by cheap ugg boots, December 31, 2009
Just because it’s a tough-as-nails ugg outlet store doesn’t mean you can’t wear it everywhere. If you want something casual, cozy,wholesale ugg boots and beautifully crafted, you can take your pick from Emu’s wide range of designer footwear. Emu Boots are high-end fashion and space-age technologies are combined to produce products that last for years. You’d be hard-pressed to find anything superior than stepping into EMU Australia’s hottest footwear.Everything is for you,merryUgg Boots christmas!
0
uggs online sale
written by uggs online sale, January 04, 2010
Today is not yesterday. We ourselves change uggs sale. How then can our works and thoughts, if they are always to be fittestuggs outlet, continue always the same?
0
UGG Boots UK | Classic UGG Boots Sale-To ensure your toes are in heaven,UGG Boots made by UGG Australia are your must-have boots.50-70% off.Love UGGs.
written by UGG Boots UK|Classic UGG Boots, January 23, 2010
Nice work .
Ugg Boots UK
is so popular in this season.
Ugg Boots have become the lastest fashion trend.please follow the step to near by vogue.
0
Chi flat iron, Chi Hair Straightener on sale,100% Quality Guarantee!
written by Chi Hair Straightener on sale, January 23, 2010
Well,This is a good post.do you know?chi hair straightener? chi hair straightener has already
an objective market share in market, and will be constantly
enhanced in future.
0
GHD hair straightener at Special price and Approved online Retailer
written by GHD hair straightener, January 23, 2010
thanks for sharing this nice post .ghd hair straightener always make you surprise
after you use it .just do as you like .
0
...
written by christian louboutin, January 23, 2010
It is a beautiful post . Now, christian louboutin
shoes also to be the trend of fashion .Many celebrities just wear them attend to lady party .do you want it ?
0
hgfhgf
written by rolex replica, January 23, 2010
rolex replica,authentic quality
0
cheap ghd
written by ghd hair straightener, February 02, 2010
Truely a nice blog and thanks for your great work. By the way,welcom to our websites:www.fashionhairfu.com . We provide cheap hair straighters, including theghd radiance set, the limited edition ghd precious gift set , cheap ghd pretty in pinkand so on. Nothing would be more suitable than these on our sites ghd flat iron. Wholesale and retail are both acceptable to us. Welcome to our site and free to look! Thank you and wish you a nice day. Good Luck!All of the product are popular around the world. In addition,ghd dark styler
ghd iv pure styler
ghd iv purple styler
ghd iv styling set
ghd iv mini styler
ghd curling irons
ghd pink flat iron
ghd turbo 2 big flat iron
ghd black flat iron
ghd dazzle flat iron
ghd camo flat iron
ghd blue nano flat iron are also very popular.our products also have a corresponding discount activities,Do NOT miss it! Wholesale and retail are both acceptable to us. Welcome to our site and free to look! Thank you and wish you a nice day. Good Luck!
0
swiss watches
written by Rolex replica, February 02, 2010
replica Rolex replica Rolex , replica Breitling replica Breitling
0
Lady Boots
written by Lady Boots, March 08, 2010
made of grade-A leather .good quanlity and fashion design,suit for morden ladies and girls.
0
mbt shoes
written by mbt shoes, March 10, 2010
The author's writing is sharp XN.chi flat irons/jordan shoes

Write comment

busy
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 02 December 2009 01:30 )
 

Next Issue / Próximo número

Fumador
English The next issue of Yareah Magazine will talk about smoking, smoke and smokers.

W
e will receive articles from today to the 20th of February and we will publish them into the digital issue. The best of them will be published on the magazine and PDF the 1st of March.

Please, register first and you will be able to send us the articles in your user section.
You can send them too by email: yareahmagazine@gmail.com

bandera española El próximo número de Yareah Magazine hablará de humo, fumadores y tabaco.

Recibiremos artículos desde hoy hasta el 20 de febrero y los publicaremos en la edición digital. Los mejores serán publicados en la revista y el DPF el 1 de Marzo.
Por favor, regístrense primero y envíenos los artículos a través de la sección usuario.
También pueden mandar los artículos por email a: yareahmagazine@gmail.com
 

Write on Yareah / Escribir en Yareah

English The next issue of Yareah Magazine will talk about smoking, smoke and smokers.

We will receive articles from today to the 20th of February and we will publish them into the digital issue. The best of them will be published on the magazine and PDF the 1st of March.

Please, register first and you will be able to send us the articles in your user section.

You can send them too by email: \n yareahmagazine@gmail.com This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

 

bandera española El próximo número de Yareah Magazine hablará de humo, fumadores y tabaco.

Recibiremos artículos desde hoy hasta el 20 de febrero y los publicaremos en la edición digital. Los mejores serán publicados en la revista y el DPF el 1 de Marzo.

Por favor, regístrense primero y envíenos los artículos a través de la sección usuario.

También pueden mandar los artículos por email a: \n yareahmagazine@gmail.com

Acceso usuarios / Login Form



Facebookfans