Why I don’t like J.R.R. Tolkien

Why I don’t like J.R.R. Tolkien
Gollum on Mount Doom

Gollum on Mount Doom

This is one article I thought I wouldn’t write never but, you know, never say never and nothing is impossible. Yesterday, in Comic-Con festival in San Diego, Peter Jackson presented the trailer of his new film The Hobbit, Bilbo Bolson’s first adventure. The book was in fact a simple divertimento for his children but one friend of Tolkien read it and recommended to Tolkien to finish the book… and it was the beginning of the trilogy composed of The Hobbit, Lord Of The Rings and The Silmarillion.

First of all, Tolkien was a philologist and we can see the importance of his studies in the three books –six books in fact-.

(Middle copy-paste from Wikipedia, I hate myself for this): he specialized in English philology at university and he worked for the Oxford English Dictionary. Also, he has studies of German and Finnish… he gave courses in Old English heroic verse, history of English, various Old English and Middle English texts…. Old and Middle English philology, introductory Germanic philology, Gothic, Old Icelandic, and Medieval Welsh. (I was in trance, sorry, the spirit of copy-paste has gone and the bad jokes man is again with you).

Tolkien participates in the I World War like Robert Graves and this generation –it’s not a casual thing that both were at Oxford- made a curious understanding between philology and literature, both influences in the next generation of writers –with Joyce, Beckett and many more-, a generation with a special interest in myths, philology and words. We all know that

Lord of the Rings

Lord of the Rings

Tolkien invented two fictional languages: a) Sindarin, called in English “Grey-elvish” or “Grey-elven”, it was the language of the Sindarin Elves of Beleriand; and b) Quenya, one of the many Elvish languages spoken by the immortal Elves. Like Joyce, he enjoyed playing with words creating new invented ones; like Graves, Tolkien deepened into the roots of Myths to create new kingdoms of imagination and fantasy.

(I must confess now: I don’t like Tolkien because I envy him. I would like to be read by thousands and thousands of readers.)

Tolkien’s influence is something like… grotesque? His legacy is not only present in thousands of books all around the world; also, his ideas and characters have inspired videogames, role plays and many more things that I cannot remember now. And Tolkien’s figure is getting bigger and bigger with every new emergent author that uses this literary fantasy formula (see, for example, Game of Thrones).

Today, Tolkien is much alive than never and, finally, that’s the reason I hate him, because I’m much died every day. Joking or not (don’t worry, I am always joking), Tolkien invented this successful formula that combines culture, myths, language and, of course, entertainment.

Still envying, I am at the feet of this great writer.

View Comments (2)

More in Books

Creatives working at The Phoenix Artist

Independent venue launches hub for London’s creative community

Yareah MagazineJuly 19, 2016

Sunday Poetry with Jenean C. Gilstrap. A Midnight Clear in Kansas

Yareah MagazineJune 19, 2016
The Nantucket Book Festival

Book lovers. The Nantucket Book Festival features a stellar line-up of authors and events

Yareah MagazineMay 11, 2016
Ceramics by Sister Augustine

Author John Schlimm has won a Christopher Award for Five Years in Heaven

Yareah MagazineMay 5, 2016
Ken O'neill. Casino Woman in Red Throwing Dice

Sunday Poetry with Jenean C. Gilstrap. Today: burn baby burn

Jenean C GilstrapApril 24, 2016
Lions painted in the Chauvet Cave. This is a replica of the painting from the Brno museum Anthropos. The absence of the mane sometimes leads to these paintings being described as portraits of lionesses. Source: Wikipedia. Author: HTO - Own work (own photo)

Sunday Poetry with Gypsy Woman, Jenean C. Gilstrap. Today: Home

Jenean C GilstrapApril 17, 2016

Yareah Magazine

Art is Everywhere and Up to You.

About Us - Press Kit - Contact Us

YM on Twitter

Top Posts & Pages

Yareah® Magazine is a Registered Trademark in the United States